This is a reflection on the Mass readings of the day.
The first reading and the Psalm today talk about God blessing His people. What a perfect theme for the feast of Mary, the Mother of God–for in the creation and sanctification of this model woman, God blessed His people indeed.
If we look at the core of many the heresies in the Church–for example, the great early heresies of Arianism and Nestorianism, in the face of which this title for Mary was proclaimed, and then the great Protestant heresies concerning salvation–we find an interesting theme.
Perhaps surprisingly, the theme is not one of trivializing sin, or one of disobedience to God/resistance to following key elements of His will. Quite the contrary. The theme is one of resisting the notion that God, in His redemptive act, can and wants to sanctify us profoundly, to the core, and exalt us to substantive participation in the divine nature.
God’s plan for us is literally so glorious that we find it too good to be true.
The early heresy Arianism’s brand of dumbing down God’s plan to create profound union between God and man was to deny this union first and foremost in Christ Himself, denying that Christ was truly God. Arius, the primary proponent of the heresy, found the notion of God Incarnate simply too much to fit in His brain. (Understandably, for truly it is too much to fit in any brain.)
The title of Theotokos or Mother of God was proclaimed in response to Nestorianism, which held essentially that the divine and human cannot mix–that Christ was basically two entities, divine and human, rather than being a single Person with two natures combined in Himself.
And so, like all things with Mary, proclamations in reference to her are directly targeted at glorifying a reality about her Son–in this case, the reality that the baby she carried within her was in fact God Himself, the Second Person of the Blessed Trinity.
The soteriology (salvation theology) of the key proponents of the Protestant Reformation essentially held that God does not sanctify us to the core; rather, He leaves us corrupt, but when He sees His Son in the flesh, He is so pleased with Him that He provides salvation to those who believe in Him.
The most exciting reality in our Christian life paradoxically has also been the most difficult for theologians to bear: That, in saving and sanctifying us, God fully purifies our nature and exalts us through intimate union with Himself to heights that we cannot even imagine, bvy means of the true, real, profound union of human and divine natures in His Son.
Theologians’ difficulty with this reality give evidence of the profoundly palpable damage that original sin and our own sin have wrought on our human psyche. The depths of the fall are such that we find it very hard to imagine being fully lifted from them.
But we must remember: No matter how close we come to God in this life, until we reach our eternal destiny, we are part of a broken world that–while not preventing God’s sanctifying action–affects us to the core of our psychology. Only faith and trust in His promise can lead us to judgements free of that false and temporary downward pull, and can lead us to taste, even here, the freedom of the Sons of God.
Ideas for conversation with the Lord: Chat with Mary about the great things He did in her life, by calling her to be Mother of God and herself to be exalted in glory and sanctification that her earthly self could never have imagined. Ask her to give you the same simplicity of faith that she had–not one that needs to understand the “how” of God’s promise in order to trust in it fully.
Follow the Author on Twitter:Follow @mvhaywilliams